Why Rupf’s apology over the Jaycee Dugard case shouldn’t be held against him if he decides to run again for sheriff

It was the apology heard around the world: Contra Costa Sheriff Warren Rupf’s blunt assessment of his department’s failure to discover kidnap victim Jaycee Lee Dugard sooner, particularly after it received a 2006 911 call that accused kidnapper Phillip Garrido was a psychotic sex addict who was housing children in tents in his back yard.

In a press conference two days after Dugard’s amazing discovery after 18 years in captivity, Rupf also acknowledged that, in 2008, an even larger team of investigators, checking up on sexual predators failed to find the hidden back yard where Phillip and his wife, Nancy, had set up an encampment for Jaycee Dugard and her two daughters with Phillip Garrido.

Rupf’s apology was quoted by news organizations all over the world, including the New York Times , national magazines, and especially newspapers and TV networks in the United Kingdom.

Rupf called a news conference to make his apologies, even as the state parole agency was declaring its pride in helping to break the case. “We are beating ourselves up over this,” Rupf said, according to the San Francisco Chronicle. “I’m first in line to offer organizational criticism, offer my apologies to the victims and accept responsibility.”

Today, I read in Lisa Vorderbrueggen’s Sunday political column in the Contra Costa Times that Rupf has delayed decision on whether he will seek re-election for Sheriff. His term ends next year, and he intended to make up his mind by Labor Day.

But he and his department “are deeply involved” in the Dugard kidnapping investigation. Vorderbrueggen doesn’t come out and say it. But by noting Rupf’s delay in making his decision, in the context of his department missing the chance to rescue Dugard several years ago–well, it raises the question of whether he’s worried that his career as sheriff is over.

Now, I’ve met Rupf. He’s a nice, friendly guy when you just meet him at some events. I hear different things about him. I don’t agree with everything he has done as sheriff, or with ways his department has handled certain cases. Yeah, members of his department blew it big time with the Dugard case–but then so did other law enforcement agencies.

And Rupf was the only leader of one of these law enforcement agencies with the spine to stand up and say, we blew it.

Do you know how unusual that is? For an elected official to admit a mistake? For the leader of a law enforcement agency to admit a mistake?

It doesn’t happen that often. In fact, it’s pretty rare, in my experience of covering cops or elected officials. They’re never wrong! Actually, lawyers are pretty bad about admitting mistakes, too. And doctors! Are they the worst?

No, you know who is absolutely the worst about admitting errors?


We are the absolute masters of being defensive in the face of criticism, and the art of self-justification. And I love how we hold others in authority–like Warren Rupf–to task for their screw ups or other unprofessional behavior.

Okay, so, back to Rupf. He did something rare. He did something that few of us in our professional lives have the courage to do. He apologized. He took resonsibility. He said, “I’m sorry.”

Whether he runs again or not, whether I’d vote for him or not if he did run, I at least give him tons of credit for this one act: taking responsibility for a big huge error in a big, huge super high-profile criminal case.

6 thoughts on “Why Rupf’s apology over the Jaycee Dugard case shouldn’t be held against him if he decides to run again for sheriff

  1. The most telling phrase here is “high profile case.” Seeking attention in the midst of a case garnering world wide attention is not honorable. Resigning for the failures of your leadership is honorable.



  2. 9:00 am…..

    You obviously do not know much about Warren Rupf or you would not have jumped in so quickly to infer that he was “seeking attention” with his apology. How dare you.

    Sheriff Rupf is the most honest and honorable person holding public office (I won't use the word potician because he is not one)that you will ever meet. He takes his job very seriously and performs it very well.

    He is a Marine through and through and I for one am thankful that he stood in front of the cameras and admitted his mistakes. You won't see that happen very often no matter what the profession.

    We would all be well served should Sheriff Warren Rupf decide to run for re-election next year.


  3. I certainly agree that most people, of any profession always have a hard time to admit their mistakes.

    But sometimes your mistakes are so blatantly obvious like when your department had visited a convicted sex offender numerous times over more than a decade, even at least at one time got a call from the public that there were little children living in the backyard of that property and still fails to notice that this guy is holding an abducted victim in captivity.

    In such a case rather than denying your mistake it seems the safest option is to go to the public apologize and say that you take responsibility.

    But what does it mean taking responsibility without punishment? I would say the most honorable and honest thing would be to step down from your position. And even that would seem like a small sacrifice compared to the years of pain and agony Jaycee Dugard and her family had to endure.


  4. boy soccer mom you are quick to give in. didn't scott peterson say he was sorry? do you forgive him too?
    18 years of missing someone, who was hiding right in front of you??? your deputies were there once a year to check up on him. there was a task force of several people, and they missed.
    But, Rupf said he was sorry, so let's re-elect him (and anon 9:53) I am sure he is a great guy at home, a marine, and has raised a nice family. But, the fact remains, he did not do his job and made a horrendous mistake, so he should resign, not run next year, and in my mind be prosecuted.
    “a great guy” – they also said that about the guy that shot up the Mcdonald's years ago, and most criminals/mass murderers were “great kids.”
    Give me a break – that is what's wrong with our society – NO ACCOUNTABILITY.


  5. I agree that Sheriff Rupf demonstrated real leadership by publicly apologizing. Unfortunately, as you noted, this kind of leadership is rare.

    The LEAP blog has an interesting post about this issue, particularly in regard to the assignment of scare police resources to investigate sex crimes.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s